- Dirt Road Magazine - FRS Radio Comparison - (dirtroad.com)
Credits
Home
F.A.Q.
Media Kit
Cover
Vendor Catalogs
Jeep Rater
Show & Tell
Yellow Pages
Projects
Site Map
E-mail Us
Jeep Forum
Ask Grant
Features
Columns
Trial & Error
Classifieds
Trading Post
Back Issues
Links
©2005 Dirt Road Magazine



When it comes to Jeep-to-Jeep communications, most of us rely on our (somewhat) trusty CB's, right? But we eventually get tired of wading from channel to channel, looking for one that is clear, or one that does not have someone yelling profanity on it.

Radios

Recently a new license-free radio has reached the market with a frequency range (UHF-FM, 462.5625-467.7125 MHz) that is not only clearer than that of the CB's AM range, but also travels farther than a hand-held CB - which can make a great difference if you get stranded while Jeeping, or even if you just want to get out and look around.




We are going to take a look at and compare the two most popular of these Family Service Radios: The Cobra microTALK and the Motorola TalkAbout.
Features:
Cobra
microTALK 3
Motorola
TalkAbout 250
MSRP/Retail
$130/$105*
$125/135**
License Required?
No
No
Output Power
500 mW
500 mW
Power Supply
4 x AAA
3 x AA
Number of Channels
14/38
14/38
Warranty
2 Years
1 Year
1-800 Support
X
Automatic Squelch
X
X
Manual Squelch/Monitor
X
X
Backlighted Display
X
(Green)
X
(Red)
Retractable Rubber Antenna
X
Call Feature
X
    Beep Call Alert
X
    Vibrating Call Alert
X
Ability to turn keypad "Beep" off
X
Ability to Scan Channels
X
(Primary & Secondary)
X
(Primary Only)
Ability to Lock the Keypad
X
X
Recessed Lock Button
X
Channel Memory
X
Voice Scrambling Option
X
Battery Meter on LCD
X
(4-segment)
X
(3-segment)
Stand By/Battery Saver Mode
X
Speaker/Microphone Jacks
X
X
Water Resistant
X
Wrist Strap
X
*=Retail pricing provided by Thomas Disributing @ 800/821-2769
**=Retail pricing provided by Field Trips @ 800/500-9266

Motorola TalkAbout:
Motorola TalkAbout 250 On the shelf at the store, the Motorola TalkAbout immediately caught our eye. It is sporty and rugged looking, and even the packaging itself is appealing. Once we got it home, however, we were in for a big surprise. The battery compartment does not seal well (there are no rubber gaskets), and the antenna does not fold or retract in any way. Another minus is that the push-to-talk botton is located directly on the face of the radio, making it so you have to hold your thumb in front of your mouth while talking. We found this to be very uncomfortable.

The TalkAbout is available in yellow, blue, anthracite (black), and for an additional charge, camoflauge. The box contains one radio with belt-clip, instruction booklet, and warranty card.

View a close-up of the Motorola's LCD display here.
View a close-up of the Motorola's LCD display backlit here.

Cobra microTALK:
Cobra microTALK 3 The Cobra microTALK, on the other hand, was an unexpected treat. Small and wimpy-looking, it is a wolf in sheep's clothing. Features galore, and a few well thought-out conveniences make it our top choice by a country mile - or two. Take away the Cobra's fancy electronic features, and you still have a better radio: The battery compartment is sealed with a latch while a rubber gasket helps keep it water-resistant, and the antenna rotates down, making the microTALK extremely portable.

Luckily for us, Cobra did think to include a plethora of electronic bells and whistles that make this radio even more of a bargain. Unlike the TalkAbout, which can only scan the primary channels, the microTALK can scan either the primary or secondary channels. This can come in handy during large gatherings, where you never know which channel a fellow Jeeper may be using. And Cobra has added "Private Call" voice scrambling to keep conversations private. It even has an alert mode to get your attention when someone is trying to contact you. You can select from an audible tone, VibrAlert (like a vibrating pager), or a combination of the two.

The microTALK is available in yellow or black (a camoflauged fabric case is also available). The packaging contains one radio with belt-clip, wrist-strap, instruction booklet, and warranty card. For safety's sake, there is also a voice-activated headset available for hands-free use while driving or hiking.

What else do you get? Built-in charging pads for use with the optional NiMH battery packs, a talk confirmation tone, and enough available accessories to customize your microTALK 'til the cows come home!

View a close-up of the Cobra's LCD display here.
View a close-up of the Cobra's LCD display backlit here.


Cobra Electronics is a recipient of the
Dirt Road Magazine's Top Choice Award!

According to the packaging (highlights):

Motorola TalkAbout - "The Serious 'Walkie-Talkie'"

  • Up to 2-mile range
  • 14 channels with channel lock
  • Channel scan
  • Crystal clear group talk
  • Audible low battery alert

  • Cobra microTALK - "The High Performance 'Walkie-Talkie'"
  • UHF/FM - Ultra clear
  • Up to 2 mile range
  • Ultra compact - Goes anywhere
  • No license or service fees
  • VibrAlert silent alert on incoming calls
  • Private Call voice scrambling
  • Full scan
  • Battery saver circuitry

  • Our Evaluation:
    Cobra
    microTALK 3
    Motorola
    TalkAbout 250
    Pricing
    ••••
    •••••
    Overall Feel
    ••••
    •••••
    Overall Look
    •••••
    ••••
    Features
    •••••
    ••••
    Ease of Use
    •••••
    •••••
    Accessibility of "Talk" Button
    ••••
    ••••
    Ruggedness
    ••••
    •••••
    Display Visibility
    ••••
    •••••
    Backlighting
    ••••
    •••••
    Portability
    ••••
    •••••
    Clarity
    ••••
    ••••
    Availability
    •••••
    ••••
    Available Accessories
    •••••
    ••••
    Overall Rating
    ••••
    3.85
    •••••
    2.77


    What it boils down to:
      We highly recommend going with the Cobra-series FRS radios. You get more quality, features, and "peace of mind" for your money. Motorola needs to take lessons from Cobra, and stop relying on their name to sell products.

    Go to Cobra's microTALK 3 page

    Go to Motorola's TalkAbout 250 page


    Channel Frequencies
    Channel MHz
    1 462.5625
    2 462.5875
    3 462.6125
    4 462.6375
    5 462.6625
    6 462.6875
    7 462.7125
    8 467.5625
    9 467.5875
    10 467.6125
    11 467.6375
    12 467.6625
    13 467.6875
    14 467.7125

    Cobra Electronics
    6500 West Cortland Street
    Chicago, Illinois 60635
    773/889-3087 Voice
    773/889-6343 Fax
    Motorola
    2419 W. 14th Steet
    Tempe, AZ 85281
    800/353-2729


    Dirt Road Magazine is sponsored by Turner 4WD Parts Co.